This God who pursues us is always calling the wrong people onto a bus that isn’t expected to arrive.
Roxburgh and Romanuk in The Missional Leader are obviously trying to stir up some controversy. You don’t mess with Jim Collins! But they’re writing to a church audience while Collins clearly wrote Good to Great for a business audience. Even his monograph painted social sectors with a broad brush. Where do parachurch mission agencies like Wycliffe fall in the continuum? I know lots of people have opinions on that, but I don’t want to give a rash answer. I think it’s worthwhile to embrace the tension and wrestle with it for a week or two in this blog. Give me your thoughts as we go along.
What happens when the wrong people are in leadership? The Bible is full of examples of unlikely leaders. You know the obvious ones, so let’s look at the book of Judges for some more obscure ones:
- Sampson, a guy with huge strengths and huge weaknesses. Probably had addiction problems, some anger problems and a taste for prostitutes.
- Gideon, the “mighty warrior” who did everything he could to lay low and dodge leadership.
- Barak, a guy appointed for leadership but who was more comfortable being in the #2 chair.
- I think my favorite is Jephthah, the son of a prostitute who was chased away by his half-brothers until they got in a bind and asked him to be their leader. He was rash, unorthodox and creative in his leadership, but he also made some stupid decisions.
All of them had major flaws, but God used each of them in their times.
Perhaps the classic example is the twelve-seat bus that Jesus put together to transform the world and launch the church. He filled seats with a few hotheads, a handful of uneducated fishermen, a couple of dire enemies (a zealot and a tax collector) and a traitor. Not the team any leader I know would assemble. Roxburgh and Romanuk again:
Look at the ordinary people Jesus begins with; this is consistent with how God has always chosen to act…. What is present here is literally that in God’s economy the Spirit is among the people of God…. God’s future is among the regular, ordinary people of God. It’s not primarily in great leaders or experts but among the people, all those people most leaders believe don’t get it.
Ouch. I’m guilty of thinking some of these people don’t get it. I have a bent to engage with leaders but write off those who aren’t interested or gifted or called to lead.
So, how should a Christian organization engage with these tensions? On the one hand, we are stewards of God’s resources, with a huge responsibility to manage our assets well. We want good management and good leadership. On the other hand, we have the verses that say God’s power is strongest when we are weak. We have the examples that God can use a man like Peter — a disciple who’s quick to speak and slow to listen, a devotee who steps out of a boat in the middle of a lake, a coward who denies a friend at his neediest moment. The wild card is what the Holy Spirit can do to fill someone and make him useful. Acts 4 describes the transformation Peter went through and names two factors: he was filled with the Holy Spirit, and he’d been with Jesus. I can’t say I’ve ever looked for those two criteria on a resume, though I have looked at previous failures and testing and how a person has grown — perhaps evidence of the Holy Spirit’s work.
There’s my challenge for you: in your hiring and development work, how are you looking for evidence of the Holy Spirit’s work?
Yes. Interesting perspective. I wonder how to compare that set of thoughts with the requirements for elder and deacon laid out in the NT – i.e. – there are some standards to be met before appointing someone as a leader. How often does the Holy Spirit “gift” someone with a new character? Do we presume the Holy Spirit will do that and so we are free to allow that thought to trump concerns about leadership character/gifting? Would be fun to continue wrestling with this!
Great, tough questions, Mike. What is the role of grace in hiring staff and considering people as missionary candidates? Writing what I did about Peter has gotten me inspired to dig into his transformation a bit more. I’m going to post some thoughts on him later this week, because the Peter in the gospels might as well be a different Peter than the one in Acts. I’ve heard it said that neither Peter or Paul would be accepted by any pastor search committee based on their resumes.